PAN-OS: SSL Forward Proxy (Outbound Decryption) - Details, Best Practices & Caveats

What is SSL Forward Proxy?

SSL Forward Proxy, commonly known as Outbound Decryption, is a Palo Alto Networks firewall feature enabling inspection of SSL/TLS encrypted traffic initiated by internal clients towards external servers (websites, SaaS applications, etc.). In today's internet where encryption is standard (~95%+ of web traffic), decrypting outbound traffic is essential for maintaining security visibility and control.

Without SSL Forward Proxy, the firewall sees only an encrypted stream, typically identified as App-ID ssl or tls . This limits the effectiveness of many Next-Generation Firewall features. By decrypting, the firewall can:

This functionality is the counterpart to SSL Inbound Inspection, which decrypts traffic coming *into* internal servers.

How SSL Forward Proxy Works: The MITM Mechanism

SSL Forward Proxy operates as a Man-in-the-Middle (MITM) between the internal client and the external server. Since the firewall doesn't possess the private keys of external web servers, it uses a different approach than Inbound Inspection:

  1. Client Initiates Connection: An internal client attempts to connect to an external HTTPS site (e.g., `https://example.com`).
  2. Firewall Intercepts: A Decryption Policy rule configured for SSL Forward Proxy matches the session.
  3. Firewall Connects to Server: The firewall initiates its *own* separate SSL/TLS connection to the actual external server (`example.com`), validating the server's real certificate.
  4. Firewall Generates Certificate: The firewall dynamically creates a new SSL certificate that mimics the identity of the original server's certificate (copying attributes like Common Name, Subject Alternative Names).
  5. Firewall Signs Certificate: The firewall signs this newly generated certificate using the private key of a special Certificate Authority (CA) certificate stored on the firewall and designated as the Forward Trust CA .
  6. Firewall Presents Certificate to Client: The firewall presents this firewall-signed certificate to the internal client instead of the real server's certificate.
  7. Client Verification: The client's browser/OS checks if the CA that signed the presented certificate (the firewall's Forward Trust CA) is trusted.
    • If Trusted: The client accepts the certificate, and the SSL/TLS handshake completes successfully between the client and the *firewall*.
    • If Not Trusted: The client's browser will display a prominent certificate warning/error, potentially blocking the connection. This underscores the critical need to deploy the Forward Trust CA to client trust stores.
  8. Decryption and Inspection: With two separate SSL sessions established (Client<->Firewall and Firewall<->Server), the firewall decrypts client traffic, inspects it using its security engines (App-ID, Threat, URL, File), re-encrypts it using the session key from the connection to the real server, and forwards it. Return traffic follows the reverse path. 
    graph TD
        Client[Internal Client] -- 1. HTTPS Request --> FW(Firewall);
        subgraph Firewall
            DecPol{Decryption Policy
Matches URL Category,
Action: Decrypt,
Type: SSL Fwd Proxy} -- Intercepts --> Traffic;
            FW_CA(Forward Trust CA
w/ Private Key) -- Signs --> TempCert(Generated Cert
Impersonates Ext Server);
            FW_Engines(Inspection Engines
App-ID, Threat Prev,
URL Filt, File Block) -- Inspect Decrypted --> Cleartext;
            SecPol{Security Policy
Allows Decrypted App,
Applies Profiles} -- Uses Decrypted App --> Cleartext;
        end
        FW -- 2. Connects & Validates --> ExtServer(External Server);
        FW -- 3. Presents Generated Cert --> Client;
        Client -- 4. Validates Cert against Trusted CAs
(MUST Trust FW_CA) --> FW;
        Cleartext -- 5. Re-encrypt & Forward --> ExtServer;

        Client <-. Encrypted Session w/ FW Cert .-> FW;
        FW <-. Encrypted Session w/ Real Cert .-> ExtServer;
        FW -- Cleartext for Inspection --> FW_Engines;

    linkStyle 0 stroke:#007bff,stroke-width:1px;
    linkStyle 1 stroke:#dc3545,stroke-width:2px,color:red;
    linkStyle 2 stroke:#fd7e14,stroke-width:1px,color:orange;
    linkStyle 3 stroke:#6f42c1,stroke-width:1px,color:purple;
    linkStyle 4 stroke:#28a745,stroke-width:1px,color:green;
    linkStyle 5 stroke:#17a2b8,stroke-width:1px,color:teal;
    linkStyle 6 stroke:#007bff,stroke-width:1px;
    linkStyle 7 stroke:#6c757d,stroke-width:1px,stroke-dasharray: 5 5;
    linkStyle 8 stroke:#6c757d,stroke-width:1px,stroke-dasharray: 5 5;
    linkStyle 9 stroke:#6c757d,stroke-width:1px,stroke-dasharray: 5 5;
Simplified SSL Forward Proxy Flow.

Configuration Overview

Key configuration steps involve:

  1. Forward Trust CA Setup: Generate or import a CA certificate on the firewall ( Device > Certificate Management > Certificates ) and mark it as Forward Trust .
  2. Forward Untrust Certificate Setup: Designate a certificate (often the same Forward Trust CA or the default firewall cert) to be used when encountering invalid server certificates (mark as Forward Untrust ).
  3. Client CA Deployment: Export the public part of the Forward Trust CA and deploy it to client trust stores (critical external step).
  4. Decryption Profile: Create profile(s) under Objects > Decryption > Decryption Profile to control decryption options (unsupported modes, certificate checks, etc.).
  5. Decryption Policy Rules: Create rules under Policies > Decryption :
    • Define "No Decrypt" rules for sensitive/problematic categories/sites (placed higher).
    • Define "Decrypt" rules matching desired traffic (e.g., by URL Category), setting Action to Decrypt and Type to SSL Forward Proxy , referencing a Decryption Profile.
  6. Security Policy Rules: Ensure rules under Policies > Security allow the traffic (initially as `ssl`, then potentially based on the decrypted App-ID) and apply relevant Security Profiles for inspection.
  7. Commit.

Best Practices

Caveats, Gotchas, and Considerations

Local SSL Decryption Exclusion Cache – Key Concepts

Decryption Best Practices Summary

Implementing SSL/TLS decryption effectively requires careful planning and adherence to best practices to maximize security benefits while minimizing user impact and performance issues. Here are key recommendations summarized from Palo Alto Networks documentation:

Certificate and Key Management:

Decryption Profile Configuration:

Decryption Policy Configuration:

Supporting Configurations & Rollout:

PCNSE Exam Focus

For the PCNSE exam, regarding SSL Forward Proxy:

SSL Forward Proxy Quiz (Expanded)

1. SSL Forward Proxy on a PAN-OS firewall is primarily used to inspect:

SSL Forward Proxy specifically deals with outbound sessions originating from clients behind the firewall connecting to external SSL/TLS services.

2. During SSL Forward Proxy, the firewall presents a certificate to the internal client. What signs this certificate?

The firewall dynamically generates a certificate mimicking the real server but signs it using its own Forward Trust CA certificate's private key. This allows it to perform the MITM interception.

3. What is the most critical deployment step required on client devices for SSL Forward Proxy to work without causing certificate errors?

Since the firewall presents certificates signed by its own Forward Trust CA (which public CAs don't know about), client browsers/OS systems will show errors unless that specific Forward Trust CA certificate is explicitly trusted by the client.

4. In a Decryption Policy rule configured for SSL Forward Proxy, what 'Type' is selected under the Options tab?

When configuring decryption for outbound traffic initiated by clients, the correct Decryption 'Type' to select in the policy rule is 'SSL Forward Proxy'.

5. Which matching criterion is most commonly used in Decryption Policy rules to selectively decrypt outbound traffic based on website content type?

URL Category is the primary mechanism for selectively decrypting traffic based on content type (e.g., decrypt 'Social Networking', 'Streaming Media' but 'No Decrypt' for 'Financial Services', 'Health and Medicine').

6. An administrator needs to prevent decryption for specific banking websites known to use certificate pinning. What is the recommended approach?

Specific exceptions for problematic or sensitive sites are handled by creating Decryption Policy rules with an Action of 'No Decrypt' and placing them higher in the rule list than the broader 'Decrypt' rules. Matching can be done via URL Category, specific URLs, or destination IPs.

7. What is a primary benefit of enabling SSL Forward Proxy?

The main driver for outbound decryption is gaining visibility into encrypted traffic to allow security engines (Threat Prevention, accurate App-ID, URL Filtering, File Blocking, Data Filtering) to inspect and control it effectively.

8. What is a significant potential challenge or caveat when implementing SSL Forward Proxy?

Certificate pinning (where an app expects a specific server certificate) and privacy implications (decrypting sensitive traffic like banking/health) are major considerations that often require creating decryption exclusions.

9. When the firewall performs SSL Forward Proxy, which certificate's private key does it use to sign the certificate presented to the internal client?

The firewall acts as a Certificate Authority for the internal client. It generates a certificate mimicking the real server but signs it using the private key associated with the certificate designated as 'Forward Trust' on the firewall.

10. Why is it recommended to create Security Policy rules to block the QUIC protocol when implementing SSL Forward Proxy?

Browsers like Chrome often try to use QUIC (over UDP) for Google services and other sites. Since the firewall typically cannot decrypt QUIC, blocking it forces the browser to fall back to standard TLS over TCP, which can then be decrypted and inspected according to policy.

11. What is the purpose of the certificate marked as 'Forward Untrust' on the firewall?

If the original server's certificate is invalid (expired, self-signed, untrusted issuer), the firewall presents the Forward Untrust certificate to the client. Since clients should *not* trust this certificate, it triggers a browser warning, alerting the user to the problem with the destination site's certificate.

12. Which Decryption policy Action should be used for URL categories like 'financial-services' and 'health-and-medicine' according to best practices?

Due to privacy concerns and potential technical issues (like pinning), best practice strongly recommends creating "No Decrypt" rules for sensitive categories like finance and health, placing these rules above general decryption rules.

13. What configuration object allows defining actions for sessions encountering unsupported protocol versions or cipher suites during decryption?

The Decryption Profile (Objects > Decryption > Decryption Profile) contains settings under the 'SSL Decryption' > 'SSL Forward Proxy' tab to control how the firewall handles sessions with unsupported parameters (e.g., Block or Allow Undecrypted).

14. Which method is recommended for distributing the Forward Trust CA certificate to a large number of Windows clients in an Active Directory environment?

Group Policy (GPO) is the standard, automated, and scalable method for deploying root certificates to domain-joined Windows machines in an Active Directory environment.

15. After enabling decryption, an administrator notices significantly higher CPU utilization on the firewall. What is a likely first step to mitigate this?

Decrypting all traffic is resource-intensive. Reducing the scope by being more selective about which URL categories or destinations are decrypted is often the most effective first step to manage CPU load before considering hardware upgrades.

16. Can the firewall use information obtained *after* decryption (like the specific App-ID) to make the *initial* decryption decision?

The decision to decrypt or not decrypt (based on the Decryption Policy) happens early in the session setup, typically based on Layer 4 info, SNI (if available), and URL category lookups. Accurate Layer 7 App-ID is usually determined *after* decryption occurs.

17. What feature allows administrators to create lists of specific domains or URLs to be excluded from decryption without needing to create a full Decryption Policy rule?

The SSL Decryption Exclusion list is specifically for sites that cause *technical* problems with decryption (like pinning). While Custom URL Categories can be used in "No Decrypt" *policies* for policy-based exclusions, the built-in exclusion list handles technical breaks.

18. Implementing SSL Forward Proxy allows URL Filtering policies to operate on:

Without decryption, URL filtering relies primarily on SNI (domain name). With decryption, the firewall sees the full cleartext HTTP request inside the tunnel, allowing filtering based on the complete URL, providing much more granularity.

19. What type of CA certificate is generally recommended for the Forward Trust role in an enterprise environment for better manageability and trust?

Using a subordinate CA signed by an already trusted internal Enterprise Root CA often simplifies client deployment (as the root is already trusted) and aligns with enterprise PKI management practices, compared to distributing a new self-signed root.

20. What is the purpose of configuring a 'No Decryption' profile and attaching it to 'No Decrypt' policy rules?

Even if you decide not to decrypt certain traffic (e.g., banking), you still want the firewall to check if the server certificate presented by the *actual* external server is valid (not expired, issued by a trusted CA). A 'No Decryption' profile allows you to configure these checks for non-decrypted sessions (except for TLS 1.3 where cert info is encrypted).

References